Thrift Stores in Lancaster, OH

We list 5 thrift, second-hand, consignment and donation stores in Lancaster, Ohio, in ZIP code 43130. Each entry links to its Google Maps page for directions, photos and current hours. Store listings from Google Maps data, March 2026. Call ahead, hours change.

Chains in this city: Goodwill (1), St. Vincent de Paul (1), Salvation Army (1). The rest are independent, charity-run or locally owned shops.

All 5 stores in Lancaster

• Good Neighbor Thrift Store - 241 Cedar Hill Rd, Lancaster, OH 43130 Open in Google Maps
• Goodwill - 505 W Fair Ave, Lancaster, OH 43130 Open in Google Maps
• Ohio Thrift Store - 1185 N Memorial Dr, Lancaster, OH 43130 Open in Google Maps
• St. Vincent de Paul Society - 424 Locust St, Lancaster, OH 43130 Open in Google Maps
• The Salvation Army Thrift Store & Donation Center - 123 E Hubert Ave, Lancaster, OH 43130 Open in Google Maps

Store listings from Google Maps data, March 2026. Call ahead, hours change. Looking somewhere else? Search by ZIP code, city or distance.

Thrift shopping in Lancaster

For chains, store types and buying tips across the state, read the Ohio thrift store guide.

Other Ohio cities with store listings

• Newark (5 stores)
• Columbus (29 stores)
• Mount Vernon (5 stores)
• Springfield (9 stores)
• Portsmouth (5 stores)
• Mansfield (7 stores)