Thrift Stores in New Castle, PA

We list 5 thrift, second-hand, consignment and donation stores in New Castle, Pennsylvania, in ZIP codes 16101, 16105. Each entry links to its Google Maps page for directions, photos and current hours. Store listings from Google Maps data, March 2026. Call ahead, hours change.

Chains in this city: Salvation Army (1), Goodwill (1). The rest are independent, charity-run or locally owned shops.

All 5 stores in New Castle

• Odds-n-Ends Consignment and Thrift - 206 E Wallace Ave, New Castle, PA 16101 Open in Google Maps
• The Salvation Army Thrift Store & Donation Center - 102 Grove St, New Castle, PA 16101 Open in Google Maps
• AMVETS Thrift Store - 1730 Wilmington Rd, New Castle, PA 16105 Open in Google Maps
• Chics Consignment - 3136 Wilmington Rd, New Castle, PA 16105 Open in Google Maps
• Goodwill New Castle - 3332 Wilmington Rd, New Castle, PA 16105 Open in Google Maps

Store listings from Google Maps data, March 2026. Call ahead, hours change. Looking somewhere else? Search by ZIP code, city or distance.

Thrift shopping in New Castle

For chains, store types and buying tips across the state, read the Pennsylvania thrift store guide.

Other Pennsylvania cities with store listings

• Meadville (5 stores)
• Pittsburgh (20 stores)
• Greensburg (7 stores)
• Erie (18 stores)
• State College (8 stores)
• Chambersburg (10 stores)